Finally watched this a few months ago, so I can finally review it. (Still haven't seen Episode 7 though
) Don't know if I have to still do spoilers, but warning at least?
I actually really enjoyed it. Even the ending, which made me incredibly sad (and I don't neccessarily agree with it a hundred percent), I enjoyed. As someone said, it did feel like it had some really good depth. And all of the characters were enjoyable, which made it even harder at the ending. As for the cgi, it didn't bother me. I didn't really noticed it actually, beyond knowing that Peter Cushing was dead. But it didn't read 'fake' to me? So that was a yay.
In the end, I was kinda hoping for someone to survive, at least K-2SO, or someone!
But I'm an eternal optimist, so that's not surprising.